found the show fresh and delightful. Although it was meant to run only one day, the Guild knew it had a success and allowed it to reopen later. The show's biggest hit--the song that Rodgers believed "made" Rodgers and Hart--was "Manhattan". The two were now a Broadway songwriting force.

During the rest of the decade, the duo wrote several hit shows for both Broadway and London, including Dearest Enemy (1925), The Girl Friend