first season as Yellow Jacket in 2024, he appeared in all 13 games, with 12 starts, where for his performance he was named first-team all-ACC. Heading into the 2025 season, Rutledge was named to the preseason all-ACC team, while also being named to the Outland Trophy watch list, as he projects to be one of the top players in the ACC and the nation. Following the 2025 season, Rutledge was named an All-American by multiple respected publication, and was named all-ACC. He took home the Piccolo Award, given to the ACC's most courageous player.

Professional career