After the band recorded a fourth album, The Morning After, in 2004, Nuñez-Fernandez left to focus on her own band, Pipas, and was replaced by Andy Warren (Adam and the Ants and The Monochrome Set). Would-Be-Goods' fifth album, Eventyr, was released in November 2008.

In October 2020 Griffin began writing and recording a song a day, with a new title (but no other guidance) provided the previous