Broadway impresario J. Lester Wallack-who would go on to serve seven terms as Shepherd-gave Montague a space in his family plot in Green-Wood Cemetery; the two rest next to each other today.

In April 1880 The Lambs moved to 34 West 26th Street, the first time under "a roof controlled by the Club." It would be the Clubhouse for 12 years. It was a period of "prosperity, joy, sorrow and calamity." In this era The Lambs entertained Gen. William Tecumseh Sherman,